PALM BEACH GARDENS, Fla. — Florida's Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) has sent a subpoena to Weiss Ratings in Palm Beach Gardens over the firm's data showing many insurers, including Citizens, have high rates of denying claims without payment.
"Our Office takes our regulatory authority to protect consumers very seriously," read a statement from the OIR. "Weiss' agency claims to be independent and thorough, and if they really want to warn consumers about their dire claims, they should have no problem answering this subpoena."
Real Estate News
Why Citizens' rate of paying claims is being questioned
In recent weeks, Martin Weiss has released information critical of Florida insurers — and in particular Citizens — which Weiss said denied close to 50% of the claims in 2023.
"Many companies, many private companies in Florida, have been denying very high rates of claims," Weiss told WPTV News recently. "Citizens, we discovered, has been denying claims at even higher rates they have denied the most claims in terms of volume."
Citizens in response has stated many denied claims are the result of flood damage — which is not part of their coverage — and because of high hurricane deductibles.
"It does not surprise me that (Insurance Commissioner Michael Yaworsky) would want to know every single shred of evidence Dr. Weiss has in making these allegations," said Lisa Miller of Lisa Miller and Associates, a former state deputy insurance commissioner. "I think the commissioner is doing the right thing by formalizing his concerns and look at Dr. Weiss' data and see if the allegations are true."
In a statement to WPTV News, Martin Weiss said the following:
"Our mission has always been to help the people of Florida navigate the insurance crisis while repeatedly meeting with the OIR and the State of Florida to offer our assistance. A subpoena was never necessary. They have our number."
The subpoena states Weiss needs to turn over data by Nov. 30.
Matt Sczesny is determined every day to help you find solutions in Florida's coverage collapse. If you have a question or comment on homeowners insurance, you can reach out to him any time.
Read WPTV's latest "Coverage Collapse" stories below:
-
The best gift cards for 2025, and which come with hidden fees
Planning to give gift cards this holiday season? Watch for hidden fees. Some gift cards offer much better value, according to WalletHub.
This is the cost of replacing stolen gifts
According to a holiday package theft study by a company that tracks home security, one in seven people were on the receiving end of porch pirates last year, a 36% increase from the year before.
Could AI be influencing grocery prices? Here's what this study found
Artificial intelligence could be shaping the prices you pay for groceries, according to a new study that reveals significant price variations for identical items on grocery delivery platforms.
Self-checkout theft rises as shoppers blame high prices
In a recent survey, more than 1in 4 admit to stealing in self checkout lines, blaming high prices and tariffs according to a new LendingTree survey.
