FORT PIERCE, Fla. — When it comes to protecting your homes, WPTV has heard your concerns about homeowners insurance. But where can you go if no one will insure your home?
We met a St. Lucie County resident who is facing that predicament.
Britt Reynolds' house sits along the Indian River Lagoon in Fort Pierce. It has nearly every upgrade possible, but insurance is still a problem.
"I got a letter Sept. 9 of this year. They're canceling me effective Sept. 30," Reynolds said.
This came despite having a metal roof and impact windows — things that homeowners are told to do. He was told by his insurer that his solar panels are a problem, along with the net metering that sells excess power back to Florida Power & Light.
"They are worried about the liability of electricity going back to FPL, someone getting shocked on the other side leaving the house," Reynolds said. "I explained to them that FPL installed the metering."
The homeowner said he never imagined his home would be uninsurable but so far he's contacted at least 24 agents with no positive results.
"Basically I've been told by all but four that I'm uninsurable," Reynolds said. "Citizens [Insurance] won't insure me."
Because of its value, even Citizens said no to insuring him. His problem is a problem many Floridians are facing — insuring a home over 50 years old.
Insurance agent Robert Norberg said solving the problem isn't easy.
"In those situations, you got to take all the bells and whistles off, get the main property coverage you can get, strip it down as much as you can to keep the cost down," Norberg said.
However, Reynolds said he can't pay off his house and self-insure or allow his mortgage company to impose a policy of $50,000 a year.
If he can't find a policy soon, he's concerned he may have to sell.
"The bottom line I feel is I'm on the water, and that's their excuse to say no," Reynolds said.
Matt Sczesny is determined every day to help you find solutions in Florida's coverage collapse. If you have a question or comment on homeowners insurance, you can reach out to him any time.
Read WPTV's latest "Coverage Collapse" stories below:
-
Synthetic motor oil shortage worsens: What oil shortage means for your wallet
A shortage of some synthetic motor oil blends is driving up oil change costs and forcing some retailers to ration supply. Will it ease anytime soon?
Aldi expands prepared food offerings with new meal line
Aldi is launching fresh ready-made meals as more shoppers turn to affordable, convenient grocery options instead of dining out.
The cost is steep in 2026 to insure new teen drivers in Florida
The cost of adding a new young driver to your auto insurance policy this year isn't pretty. Florida families can expect to shell out $651 a month to insure new young drivers.
One ingredient, multiple meals: Versatile foods that stretch your grocery budget
With the cost of groceries so high, why buy proteins or vegetables that can only be used in one meal? These versatile foods can feed your family for several days.
