NewsTreasure CoastRegion St Lucie CountyFort Pierce

Actions

'Stop the bleed': Elected officials aim to oust Fort Pierce City Commissioner James Taylor

WPTV's Kate Hussey spoke to State Representative Toby Overdorf who says the governor is working on an action plan
Elected Officials work to Oust City Commissioner
Posted
and last updated

FORT PIERCE, Fla. — Elected officials on the Treasure Coast are calling for urgent action to remove a Fort Pierce city commissioner charged with child exploitation.

WATCH BELOW: 'The least he could do is submit a resignation,' State Representative Toby Overdorf tells WPTV

Elected officials aim to oust Fort Pierce city commissioner

Thursday, St. Lucie County deputies arrested 38-year-old James Taylor, a sitting Fort Pierce city commissioner, following a multi-state investigation.

Sheriff Richard Del Toro said Taylor was sending nude photos to a 12-year-old in Illinois and was requesting nude photos in return.

"These alleged activities are beyond the ability to even really be able to speak about them, that's how bad this is," said fellow City Commissioner, Michael Broderick.

As of Friday afternoon, Taylor was still in the St. Lucie County jail after a judge Friday morning upped his bond from $250,000 to $360,000. Taylor faced the court stoic and silent as his attorney declined to comment on his behalf, but did tell the judge he would be meeting his client at 1 p.m.

Now, Broderick is calling for Taylor's immediate removal, but tells WPTV the city can't do it themselves. According to the city's charter, it's up to Taylor to resign or for Gov. Ron DeSantis to step in.

WATCH BELOW: Fort Pierce City Commissioner James Taylor appears in court

Fort Pierce commissioner in court to face child exploitation charges

"That's why I'm taking the course of action with our other elected officials to get the governor's office involved and focused on this," said Broderick. "The city needs to stop the bleeding and start healing now. So, we need either that letter of resignation, or for the governor to take swift action."

When asked if the governor has the power to do that, state Rep. Toby Overdorf, R-Stuart, said he does.

"He does have the ability to do that. He is our chief executive here in the state, and I've spoken to the governor's office, I've spoken to the various people in there," said Overdorf.

Overdorf, one of the legislators Broderick called on, said Taylor had until 4 p.m. Friday to resign, a deadline he missed. Now, he says the governor is working on an action plan.

"What they're doing is taking it through the legal side of it right now and making sure whatever move they make is perfectly within the law," said Overdorf. "They've heard us. They understand how adamant we are to remove this predator from office, and we're working on it."

Fort Pierce City Commissioner James Taylor appears in a St. Lucie County courtroom July 25, 2025, a day after he was arrested on 24 felony counts.

Fort Pierce

City commissioner appears in court, bond set at $360K

Scott Sutton

Both Overdorf and Broderick said they're shocked and startled by Taylor's arrest. He's not only a sitting commissioner, but is also involved with the Treasure Coast Night to Shine, a prom event for local children, according to photos on it's website and on Facebook.

"'Aghast,' is the word that comes to mind, because I was just so startled by it. No doubt, here's a person who has led a secret life, a secret predator life," said Overdorf. "The least he could do is submit a resignation and allow for that healing process to begin."

"The interesting conundrum here is that Commissioner Taylor, as we sit here and speak, is still a sitting commissioner. He has every right, if he's bonded out of jail, to attend that meeting as an elected official," said Broderick. "The city has no authority here to do anything, unfortunately, and I understand the reasons why, but this does point out a serious problem with elected officials that are involved in corrupt behavior."

Broderick said if Taylor is removed from office, the city charter requires a special election to fill his seat. Commissioners have scheduled a special emergency meeting for 5 p.m. Monday to discuss this issue.

Read more of WPTV's coverage below:

Fort Pierce City Commissioner James Taylor

Fort Pierce

Fort Pierce city commissioner arrested in child exploitation case

Scott Sutton
Screenshot 2025-07-24 at 2.18.33 PM.png

Fort Pierce

‘TRAGIC DAY': Officials, business owners react to arrest of city commissioner

Aja Dorsainvil
Broderick Reacts to Taylor Arrest

Fort Pierce

'CITY NEEDS TO DO BETTER': Commissioner decries colleague's arrest

Kate Hussey
Toby Overdorf

Fort Pierce

State representative says city commissioner should be 'removed from office'

Ange Toussaint