MoneyReal Estate News


Insurance cancellations, rate hikes force homeowners to search for options

'Insurance market ... at a place where it is unstable,' insurance consumer advocate says
House, Home, Neighborhood
Posted at 9:00 AM, May 26, 2021
and last updated 2021-05-26 21:03:59-04

BOYNTON BEACH, Fla. — Florida homeowners are scrambling for options as more insurance companies are raising rates and in some cases canceling policies.

"You're going to have to do a lot of leg work, and you really need to because you got to save yourself the money," said homeowner Steve Eppley of Boynton Beach.

MORE: Residents dumbfounded by rising cost of home insurance

Eppley said his homeowner's insurance premium jumped nearly $1,000 during the winter, forcing him to try and look elsewhere for insurance.

Steve Eppley, Boynton Beach resident
Boynton Beach resident Steve Eppley speaks about the increase of home insurance rates and his decision to self insure once his mortgage is paid off.

"I contacted 11 different companies," Eppley said.

He eventually found a solution with another company.

"My rate is almost identical to what I paid before the rate hike," Eppley said.

"The insurance market is really at a place where it is unstable at this point," said Tasha Carter, Florida's Insurance Consumer Advocate.

Facebook Q&A: Rising home insurance costs in Florida

Carter said losses from Hurricanes Irma and Michael, along with a rise in fraudulent claims, have led many companies to take action.

She said shopping around is advisable, especially through an insurance broker, but that is only one option.

"Another option is to review your insurance policy to ensure they take advantage of all eligible premium discounts and to ensure they are not paying for coverage they don't need," Carter said.

For many left without insurance, the only option is Citizens, the state-sponsored insurer of last resort.

Tasha Carter, Florida's Insurance Consumer Advocate
Tasha Carter outlines what Florida residents can do to cut the cost of their home insurance.

"That's a realistic solution primarily based on the fact the most recent statistic I've read is that Citizens is growing by about 4,000 policies per week, so that means they are willing to insure," Carter said.

"Citizens is the last one I would ever think of," Eppley said.

He said he plans to self-insure his home once his mortgage is paid off.

"To me, it means I'm just going to take what I normally would pay, and I'll invest it in something liquid that I can get at if I need it," Eppley said. "I just don’t have faith in insurance companies."

Tool allows homeowners to compare home insurance prices

However, Carter said there are red flags to self-insuring, particularly after a destructive hurricane, which could lead to extreme repair and replacement costs.

She said homeowners are better off finding an insurer they like and can afford.

"It is worth a consumer reaching out to their agent to determine whether or not they can shop around and find the same or similar coverage with a different company at a lower premium," Carter said.

Florida's Office of Insurance regulation offers a comparison tool on its website to help homeowners compare policy and rates.