NewsLocal NewsInvestigations


West Palm Beach catfishing victim shares online dating warning ahead of Valentine's Day

Nicole Hayden, boyfriend share story to spread awareness about catfishing
Posted at 5:06 PM, Feb 13, 2023
and last updated 2023-02-13 17:07:30-05

WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. — A new study by found Florida to be the No. 2 most catfished state in 2022, prompting a West Palm Beach catfishing victim and her boyfriend to share their story.

"I'm not able to have Facebook because I've been taken down like 25 times," Alessandro Cinquini, who lives in Miami, told WPTV.

That's because Cinquini told WPTV online imposters have been stealing his photos and creating fake profiles for years, using them to catfish women.

One of them is Nicole Hayden from West Palm Beach.

"I was just on Instagram and I got a message — a DM — from a profile," Hayden said. "After about four or five days, I realized that it was probably a catfisher."

So, Hayden looked up the real Alessandro.

"I had replied to one of his stories and, I don't know, it was about, like, three hours later, he replied back, and the rest is history from there,” Hayden said.

More than a year later, Hayden and Cinquini are now dating and working together to spread awareness about catfishing.

"If you think about the amount of online scams that there in any kind of sector, from romances, finances, crypto, it can be very hard to identify and distinguish what's true from what's not true," Cinquini said.

According to a new study by, Florida is the second-most catfished state with 1,738 victims losing $70,483,554 in 2022, with an average loss of $40,554 per victim.

Florida is second-most catfished state
Florida is the second-most catfished state with more than 1,700 victims in 2022, according to

"They're funneling money through multiple victims and so they're saying, 'Hey, my cousin Joe is going to send you $5,000. If you can take that money and convert it into crypto,'" David McClellan, founder of, said.

McClellan said the No. 1 sign that you're being catfished is when the person starts asking you for money.

"The other thing, too, is if somebody won't video chat, McClellan said. "...Anybody who just falls in love with you right away and, you know, starts telling you all of these wonderful things."

When talking to anyone online, the FBI suggests researching the person's photo and profile through a reverse image search, which you can do through sites like

The FBI also suggests asking a lot of questions and if a person promises to meet you in person but always comes up with an excuse, that's a major red flag.

Cinquini has one more piece of advice for singles looking for love.

"Don't hide behind the phone," he said. "Be aware of scams, of course, be aware of impersonation, but if you want to do something, like a girl, go approach her and do things a little bit more old school and I think it's going to work."

Email the Contact 5 Investigators
Share your news tips and story ideas with WPTV's investigations team.