App.net: Twitter or Facebook without ads, would you pay?

(CNN) -- Sure, lots of folks might be excited about a Twitter-like social network with no ads or annoying "promoted tweets."

But would they pay for it?

The founders of App.net think so, and so far they've found more than 10,000 people who agree with them.

The startup promises a "real-time feed" that will never be supported by ads. Instead, they'll charge a fee that, at least for now, looks to be about $50. That's how much it took to support a Kickstarter-like fundraising campaign that has netted more than $670,000 and wraps up Monday.

Founder and CEO Dalton Caldwell says he's been disappointed by the advertising models of sites like Twitter and Facebook and thinks users will be willing to plunk down money for an alternative.

"If we're selling a service, our customers are our users and our job is to make our users happy," he said in a video promoting the service. "If we have a free, ad-supported service, our customers are our advertisers and our job is to make our advertisers happy.

"I think that a lot of the friction we're seeing from these disappointing services are just a reflection that all the financial incentive has to do with pleasing advertisers and not the user base."

The logic contains plenty of not-so-veiled swipes at both Twitter and Facebook. After gaining widespread popularity with no real means of making money, Twitter has begun selling promoted tweets, promoted trends and promoted accounts.

But it's also kept a firm grip on its ecosystem by not allowing much leeway for outside developers to tinker.

Caldwell promises to do the opposite.

The multibillion-dollar profits of Facebook come primarly from advertising, leading to a commonly repeated line that Caldwell appears to echo: "If you're not paying for a service, you're not the customer -- you're the product."

(If that wasn't clear enough, there's also the bristly open letter Caldwell wrote to Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg earlier this month, in which he pledges "to never write another line of code for rotten-to-the-core 'platforms' like Facebook or Twitter.")

But the question remains: Will users be willing to pay to use a social network? It would be a model that's never been successful before.

Michael Gartenberg, a tech-industry analyst with research firm Gartner Inc., sees some potential. Avoiding ads and opening the service up to developers could offer a glimpse at what Twitter could have become if its creators took a different path, he said.

"I think people are getting hung up on the $50 thing right now," said Gartenberg, who predicts that a membership fee for App.net will ultimately be less than that.

"It was about, 'Are people serious enough about this as an idea to put $50 on the line to help try to create the kind of service they want?" The success of their fundraiser "shows there's definitely a demand," he said.

According to the fundraiser, $50 amounts to "pre-paying a full year of 'member' tier service." Developers pay $100, and big spenders who pony up $1,000 -- as of Monday morning, 60 folks had pledged that much -- get developer access, phone support and a meeting with Caldwell in San Francisco.

This isn't Dalton's first crack at social media.

In 2003, he co-founded iMeem, a social site on which users shared music and videos, and in 2010 launched PicPlz, a mobile photo app that allowed users to add visual effects. iMeem was acquired by Myspace and, in June, PicPlz announced it was shutting down as Facebook-aligned Instagram continued to dominate the photo-sharing space.

Is App.net bound for the same fate? Other efforts that generated initial buzz have faded.

Most notably, Diaspora became one of Kickstarter's first success stories, raising $200,000 in 2010 to launch a "privacy-aware," open-source alternative to Facebook. But it took months to actually launch and, two years later, remains a relatively tiny network that's home only to the most dedicated techies.

App.net "is a really interesting experiment," Gartenberg said. "Time will tell if there's a business here. But when Twitter started, I don't think anyone knew there was a business there either. It was a way to tell people what you had for lunch."

App.net is currently open in an early "alpha" version for donors. Caldwell emphasizes that a great deal of work needs to be done before the platform is finished. But he wanted to provide something to show backers that the service is on its way.

"Along these lines, there are still a great many questions that need to be answered before App.net should be thought of as an operating service, rather than just an alpha prototype," he wrote.
 
™ & © 2012 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

Read more

Experts say assume nothing when you upload Facebook photos because private ones may become public Experts say assume nothing when you upload Facebook photos because private ones may become public

Have you ever checked to see what the public sees when they view your Facebook page? Just because you thought something was private doesn't mean it's not public.

Facebook 2013 study: What are your kids looking at online? Facebook 2013 study: What are your kids looking at online?

Relieved your kids aren't posting embarrassing messages and goofy self-portraits on Facebook? They're probably doing it on Instagram and Snapchat instead.

Facebook fake likes crackdown: Fake accounts purged Facebook fake likes crackdown: Fake accounts purged

The result has been lower numbers on fan pages, including some of the site's most popular ones, but no actual loss of real followers.

Facebook helps doctors with diagnosis Facebook helps doctors with diagnosis

Facebook isn't just for connecting with friends -- doctors are finding uses for the social network in diagnosis.

Facebook (FB) stock: Mark Zuckerberg, is he to blame for Facebook Facebook (FB) stock: Mark Zuckerberg, is he to blame for Facebook's slumping stock?

Facebook has had a rough first three months as a public company. The social network's stock has performed poorly since going public in May, and on Monday morning it dropped to an all-time low of $18.75.

Facebook Apple iOS iPhone app update Facebook Apple iOS iPhone app update

Beginning Thursday, users can upgrade. The Apple app is the first to launch; Facebook wouldn't comment on when its Android and other mobile apps might get a revamp.

Facebook message backfires: Port St. Lucie boy Facebook message backfires: Port St. Lucie boy's 'joke' ends with his arrest

The Port St. Lucie teenager said his message was meant as a joke. 

Facebook Facebook 'want' button? New way to share might be on the way

Reports indicate that Facebook may be in the works of developing a "want" button as a way for users to share coveted items with their friends.

9 Facebook features for frequent users 9 Facebook features for frequent users

Facebook often gets a lot of publicity when it makes major changes to its Web layout, but other features slip through the cracks. Here are nine features via Mashable that you might not have realized Facebook offered.

Facebook email change: How to change your new @facebook.com email address Facebook email change: How to change your new @facebook.com email address

If you're a Facebook user, you have a @facebook.com email address, whether you use it or not. Facebook is now automatically posting those addresses to users' profiles and displaying them as the default email address.