Chris Kyle, Eddie Ray Routh shooting case: Lines drawn over gun ownership and mental health
Halimah Abdullah, CNN
8:45 AM, Feb 5, 2013
WASHINGTON -- The shooting death of a former Navy SEAL, who spent his post-military career advocating for veterans suffering from post traumatic stress disorder, highlights long-standing differences over gun rights and mental health.
Chris Kyle, the author of the best-selling "American Sniper," and Chad Littlefield, 35, also a veteran, were gunned down on Saturday while shooting for fun at a gun range southwest of Fort Worth, law enforcement officials said.
Eddie Ray Routh, 25, a former Marine, was held on a capital murder warrant, police said.
Few details about the suspect have emerged, but authorities believe Routh may suffer from some sort of mental illness.
He was on a suicide watch at the Erath County jail, Sheriff Tommy Bryant said.
Braynt said Routh had to be physically restrained during an incident at the lockup on Sunday night.
Authorities said Kyle,38, often took veterans with post traumatic stress out to the gun range as a way of bonding with and mentoring them.
Routh, Kyle and LIttlefield arrived at the range together, police said. While Kyle and Littlefield were friends and associates, their connection to Routh was not clear.
But Bryant said that Routh's mother, a longtime schoolteacher, "may have reached out to Mr. Kyle to try and help her son."
The high-profile case brought national attention to Kyle's work with veterans.
"Chris Kyle's death seems to confirm that 'he who lives by the sword dies by the sword.' Treating PTSD at a gun range doesn't make sense," former Texas Republican Rep. Ron Paul tweeted on Monday.
But what seems like common sense to some is viewed by others as another assault on the Second Amendment.
Those types of concerns are what prompted a heated debate last December as lawmakers worked to approve a defense policy bill.
Republican Sen. Tom Coburn pushed and then backed away from an amendment to block the Department of Veteran Affairs from automatically entering the names of veterans deemed "mentally incompetent" to handle their finances from having their names entered into a national background check system, thereby blocking them from gun ownership.
Instead, the Oklahoma physician wanted those case decided by a judge rather than a federal agency unless those veterans had been "found by a judicial authority to be a danger to themselves or to others."
"We're not asking for anything big," Coburn said at the time. "We're just saying that if you're going to take away the Second Amendment rights -- they ought to have it adjudicated, rather than mandated by someone who's unqualified to state that they should lose their rights."
New York Democratic Sen. Chuck Schumer pushed back argued that "you should not have a gun" whether "you are a veteran or not and you have been judged to be mentally infirm."
National Rifle Association President David Keene said at a recent media event that his organization supports reforms that would make it tougher for mentally ill people to get guns.
Mayors Against Illegal Guns aired an ad during the Super Bowl advocating universal background checks for gun sales.
Federal law makes it illegal to sell or give a firearm to anyone who "has been adjudicated as a mental defective or has been committed to any mental institution."
Statistics from the FBI's National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) show about 1 percent of applicants who failed a background check over the past 14 years, or 10,180 people, were turned down for reasons related to mental health.
Overall rejections represented a fraction of prospective gun sales and most involved applicants with criminal records.
Federally licensed gun shops must use the National Instant Criminal Background Check System, or NICS. Private sellers and gun shows have no background check requirement.
But information in the national background check system is incomplete, particularly involving mental health records, investigations have found.
Critics blame what they call a huge legal loophole, according to one study.
"PTSD is rarely associated with homicidal violence," Michael Welner, a forensic psychiatrist who has worked on cases of Iraq and Afghanistan veterans charged with violent crimes, told CNN's Soledad O'Brien.
"PTSD is very commonly associated with a number of other conditions that are regularly attached to violence, alcoholism, personality disorder, depression. So diagnostically, PTSD may be relevant and it may just be part of the picture, including traumatic brain injury," Welner said.
Expanding some background checks is under consideration in Congress as lawmakers respond to public and political pressure for stricter laws following December's shooting massacre at a Connecticut elementary school.
Possible steps include better monitoring of people with mental illness to prevent them from obtaining firearms.
Mayors Against Illegal Guns aired an ad during the Super Bowl advocating universal background checks
for gun sales.
President Barack Obama also reiterated his call on Monday for comprehensive steps to address gun violence, including expanded background checks.